
Nyack, NY – Two Rockland County hospitals received different ratings in a national patient safety evaluation released Wednesday, November 18, with Montefiore Nyack Hospital earning an A and Good Samaritan Hospital in Suffern receiving a C.
The ratings were issued by The Leapfrog Group, an independent nonprofit organization that evaluates hospitals throughout the United States on their ability to prevent medical errors, infections, accidents and injuries.
The organization’s Hospital Safety Grade program evaluates general hospitals twice annually, assigning letter grades ranging from A to F. The assessments are intended to provide patients with information about hospital safety and encourage healthcare facilities to improve their practices.
Montefiore Nyack Hospital was one of 11 hospitals across the Hudson Valley to receive an A in the fall 2026 evaluation. Good Samaritan Hospital, which serves residents of western Rockland County and surrounding communities, received a C.
The findings were also documented in regional reporting by Daily Voice and Patch, which identified the individual hospital ratings.
According to The Leapfrog Group, the grades are calculated using available hospital performance data covering patient safety practices and outcomes. Measures include hospital-acquired infections, complications following surgery, medication safety, patient falls and procedures designed to reduce preventable injuries.
The evaluation also considers hospital systems and staffing practices that can influence patient safety.
An A represents the highest grade in Leapfrog’s evaluation system, while a C indicates performance within a lower scoring range. However, the grades do not provide a complete assessment of a hospital’s overall medical quality, specialized services or individual physicians.
The fall report included 2,367 graded hospitals nationwide. Of those, 900 received an A, 774 earned a B and 655 received a C. Another 35 hospitals were assigned a D, while three received an F.
New York ranked 18th nationally in the percentage of hospitals receiving A grades, with 28.9 percent of its graded facilities earning the highest rating.
Several other Hudson Valley hospitals received A grades, including White Plains Hospital, Phelps Hospital in Sleepy Hollow, Northern Westchester Hospital in Mount Kisco, Putnam Hospital in Carmel and St. Anthony Community Hospital in Warwick.
Other hospitals in the region received lower grades. Westchester Medical Center in Valhalla and Bon Secours Community Hospital in Port Jervis each received a C, while Garnet Health Medical Center in Middletown earned a B.
The Leapfrog Group uses publicly reported healthcare data and information submitted by hospitals to calculate its ratings. Its methodology is designed to compare patient safety performance across different medical facilities.
For the fall 2026 evaluation, the organization did not assign grades to certain hospitals that had not participated in its 2025 or 2026 hospital surveys. The decision followed a federal court ruling in Florida concerning the organization’s grading practices.
Leapfrog reported that 447 hospitals nationwide were listed without assigned grades under the revised approach.
Although hospital safety ratings provide a way to compare facilities, the results have limitations. A hospital’s grade reflects specific measures available during the reporting period and does not guarantee the outcome of an individual patient’s treatment.
Similarly, a lower grade does not necessarily mean that every department or service within a hospital performs below national standards.
The organization also emphasized the importance of making hospital safety information available alongside healthcare pricing data, allowing patients and employers to consider both cost and quality when evaluating medical services.
For Rockland County residents, the new ratings offer additional information when selecting hospitals for planned procedures and other nonemergency medical services.
Montefiore Nyack Hospital and Good Samaritan Hospital continue to provide emergency, inpatient and outpatient medical care to the surrounding region.
Residents can review the complete ratings, individual safety measures and previous hospital grades through The Leapfrog Group’s website at www.HospitalSafetyGrade.org.
The next regular evaluation is scheduled for spring 2027.

