
Nanuet, NY – Authorities have released additional information about the November 18 train collision that killed a 55-year-old Rockland County woman at the New Clarkstown Road railroad crossing in Nanuet, including new findings about how her vehicle became trapped on the tracks.
The victim, identified by Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) Police as Basheva Frank, 55, of Spring Valley, died Wednesday morning after an NJ Transit commuter train struck her Toyota SUV and pushed the vehicle into her as she stood outside.
The collision occurred at approximately 8 a.m. near the Spring Valley Marketplace shopping center, at the New Clarkstown Road crossing.
According to MTA Police, the train involved was Pascack Valley Line Train 1620, which was traveling eastbound from Spring Valley toward Hoboken, New Jersey.
Investigators reviewed witness statements and video footage to establish the circumstances leading up to the collision.
Their preliminary findings indicate that Frank was driving southbound on New Clarkstown Road when her SUV stopped on the railroad crossing between the tracks.
Police determined that Frank attempted to move forward to clear the crossing but was unable to do so because another vehicle had stopped directly ahead of her.
Frank subsequently exited the SUV and was standing outside when the approaching train struck the vehicle.
The force of the collision pushed the SUV along the tracks and into Frank. Emergency responders later found her beneath the vehicle.
Rockland Paramedic Services pronounced Frank dead at the scene at 8:26 a.m.
According to MTA Police, none of the passengers or crew members aboard the train sustained injuries.
Authorities also examined the railroad crossing’s warning equipment following the collision. Investigators reported that the warning system was functioning properly, with the flashing lights operating and the crossing gate lowered.
The findings provide additional information about the circumstances of the crash but do not represent a final investigative determination.
The incident prompted an emergency response involving local law enforcement, fire departments, medical personnel and railroad authorities.
New Clarkstown Road was temporarily closed in both directions near the crossing while responders worked at the scene.
Rail operations were also affected. Pascack Valley Line service between Spring Valley and Nanuet was suspended in both directions during the emergency response and investigation.
Frank was a teacher at Rosenbaum Yeshiva of North Jersey, according to local reporting from Monsey Scoop and VINnews.
Monsey Scoop identified Frank as a New Hempstead resident, while MTA Police identified her residence as Spring Valley. Authorities have not publicly explained the difference in the reported locations.
Frank was married to Rabbi Daniel Frank, according to community reports. Her death prompted expressions of grief from family members, colleagues and members of the local Jewish community.
Funeral services were held Wednesday evening, November 18, at Bais Hamedrish Kneses Yisroel on Union Road in New Hempstead. Local reports indicated that burial arrangements were made for Israel.
The fatal collision occurred one day after another train-related incident in Clarkstown.
On Tuesday, November 17, a CSX freight train struck an occupied vehicle near the Pine View Road railroad crossing in West Nyack at approximately 7:43 a.m.
According to information previously provided by CSX and Clarkstown Police, no injuries were reported in that collision. The circumstances remained under investigation, and authorities have not identified any connection between the two incidents.
The incidents have brought attention to railroad crossings in Rockland County, particularly where traffic congestion can leave motorists with limited room to maneuver.
Federal railroad safety guidance advises drivers not to enter a railroad crossing unless there is enough space on the opposite side for their entire vehicle.
Motorists whose vehicles become trapped on railroad tracks are advised to exit immediately and contact emergency authorities.
These safety recommendations are general guidance and do not establish whether different actions would have prevented Wednesday’s fatality.
As of Thursday, November 19, MTA Police had not announced a final determination concerning the collision or any criminal charges.
The investigation remains ongoing.

