By Kim Anderson
SPRING VALLEY, NY – A long-brewing campaign to eliminate Spring Valley’s village government advanced this week when residents submitted formal petitions calling for dissolution.
As first reported by the Monsey Scoop, organizers delivered paperwork to the Village Clerk of Spring Valley on July 1st 2025 to dissolve the village government. This triggered a 10-day window to verify that each signature belongs to a registered Spring Valley voter and that the petitions satisfy Article 17-A of New York’s General Municipal Law.
If the Clerk certifies a sufficient number of valid names, the Village Board must place a referendum on the Nov. 4 general-election ballot, giving Spring Valley’s 33,000 residents the power to decide the municipality’s future.
What happens next
- Signature review: The Clerk will compare each autograph against county voter rolls and weed out duplicates or ineligible signers.
- Scheduling the vote: Certification automatically sets a referendum date—no additional board action required.
- Referendum: A simple majority “yes” dissolves the village.
- Dissolution plan: Within 180 days of voter approval, the Board must draft a plan detailing how police, sanitation, zoning, public works and other services would transfer—likely to the Towns of Ramapo and Clarkstown. Public hearings and amendments can stretch the transition out as far as mid-2027.
Supporters vs. opponents
- Pro-dissolution coalition: Argues that wiping out a layer of government will trim property taxes, cut duplicative administration and streamline services under town departments already serving surrounding hamlets.
- Opponents: Counter that the move risks diminished local representation, potential service disruption and the erosion of Spring Valley’s cultural identity—especially for its diverse, majority-minority population.
Recent Efforts to Dissolve Villages in the Hudson Valley
If voters approve, Spring Valley would join a small number of villages in the Hudson Valley that have attempted to disband. South Nyack residents voted to dissolve in December 2020; the village ceased to exist on April 1, 2022, with Orangetown assuming municipal duties.
In Orange County, residents of Highland Falls NY attempted to dissolve the village in 2021, citing duplication of services between the village and its encompassing Town of Highlands. The effort failed, but this year led to a change of government leadership, with Mayor Joe D’Onofrio stepping down after heading a controversial administration that left the Village $17 million dollars in debt.
What’s Next
Spring Valley is one of New York’s largest villages by population and its commercial hub. A “yes” vote would shift millions of dollars in budgeting authority, dozens of employees and critical planning decisions to the town of Ramapo.
The coming weeks—first the signature count, then heated campaigning—will determine whether that question lands before voters this November and, ultimately, whether the 115-year-old village government survives.